The honest comparison

Porchlight vs Smith.ai

Smith.ai is the biggest name in AI receptionists: an AI that answers first, trained human agents who can step in, and more than 25 million calls handled. If you want a person on standby, they are the benchmark. Here is what that costs — and where a flat-price bot built for your trade does the same job for less.

Porchlight BotsSmith.ai
Who answersYour named bot — a specialist for your trade, trained on your website, your prices, your hoursAn AI receptionist first; trained human agents can take over a call
Monthly priceFirst month free, then $49.99/mo for months 2–7, then $99/mo — flatAI answering from $1.60 per call; plan bundles from $300/mo
At 300 calls a month$49.99 flat — the same as at 15 callsAbout $480 at the per-call rate, before any human-agent time
The meterNone. No per-call rate, no per-minute rate, no overage chargesPer call on the AI plans; human-agent work billed on top
Where it answersYour phone, your website chat, and your texts — one bot, every doorYour phone line and your website chat
The work it doesAnswers, books appointments, takes orders and deposits, captures leads — and reads a customer's photo of the problem before anyone drives outAnswers, qualifies and books, runs intake — strongest in legal intake, with human backup
Track recordNew and small — and every bot answers live in a demo so you can judge the work yourself, today25M+ calls handled, 5,000+ law firms, a deep stack of published reviews
TrialFirst month free — the real product, on your real business; month two free too if it books nothing30-day money-back guarantee

Smith.ai prices from their published pricing pages, checked November 2026.

Where Smith.ai wins

Three places, honestly. A human can step into a hard call — if your callers regularly need a person's judgment mid-conversation, that safety net is real. Their legal intake is deep, built over thousands of firms. And their proof stack is the category's best: tens of millions of calls, and reviews everywhere you look. If those matter more than the bill, hire them with our blessing.

Where Porchlight wins

The meter. Per-call pricing means your best month — the one where the phone rings off the hook — is also your most expensive. Porchlight is one flat price at 15 calls or 500, the same bot covers your website chat and your texts, it knows your trade and your real prices because it learned them from your website, and it reads the photo your customer sends of the leak, the panel, or the roof. And every bot on this site answers live in a demo, so you can hear exactly what your customers will hear before you spend a dollar.

Build my bot — first month free Hear a bot work first