Upfirst is a good, cheap AI answering service for the phone. Porchlight is a front desk for the whole business. Here is the side-by-side, with their published prices and ours, so you can do the math yourself.
| Porchlight Bots | Upfirst | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A named AI front desk for your trade — trained on your website, your prices, your hours | An AI answering service for your phone line |
| Monthly price | First month free, then $49.99/mo for months 2–7, then $99/mo — flat | From $24.95/mo for 30 calls; $59.95 for 90 calls; $159.95 for 300 calls |
| At 150 calls a month | $49.99 flat for months 2–7 (then $99) — the same as at 15 calls | About $119.95 — 90 calls included, the rest billed per call |
| The meter | None. No per-call cap, no per-minute rate, no overage charges | Per call: extra calls cost $0.70–$1.50 each, depending on the plan |
| Where it answers | Your phone, your website chat, and your texts — one bot, every door | Your phone line |
| The work it does | Answers, books appointments, takes orders and deposits, captures leads — and reads a customer's photo of the problem before anyone drives out | Answers, books appointments, transfers calls, sends texts |
| Who answers | A specialist for your trade — Rusty for roofers, Flo for plumbers, Justine for law firms — who knows your business | A general AI receptionist |
| Trial | First month free — the real product, on your real business | 14 days free, no card required |
Upfirst prices from their published pricing pages, checked November 2026.
If you get fewer than about 30 calls a month and all you need is the phone answered, Upfirst's $24.95 Starter is cheaper than us, and it is a solid service. We won't pretend otherwise.
The moment your calls climb — or your customers reach you anywhere besides the phone — the per-call meter starts costing more than our flat price, and it still only covers the phone. Porchlight's price is the same at 15 calls or 500, and the same bot covers your website and your texts, does the booking and the order-taking itself, and can read the photo your customer sends of the leak, the panel, or the roof.
Build my bot — first month free Hear a bot work first